Ferry service on course for 2004
  Tuesday, June 24, 2003
Muskegon Chronicle
Dave Alexander



It's full speed ahead for ferry service between Muskegon and Milwaukee in 2004.

The U.S. Maritime Administration has granted Lake Express LLC a $14.5 million federal loan guarantee to construct a new high-speed ferry boat. That ferry is expected to begin Muskegon-Milwaukee operations early next summer.

The news hit Muskegon Monday afternoon, prompting community leaders to reach for superlatives as they began reacting to the Lake Express announcement.

" This is another great day for the Muskegon community," Muskegon Mayor Steve Warmington said.

The "commitment letter" received Monday by the ferry service developers at Lubar & Co. in Milwaukee is the word Muskegon officials have been waiting for since 1970, when the Milwaukee Clipper ceased operations. Restoration of cross-lake ferry service has become Muskegon County's No. 1 economic development objective.

" We are pleased to announce that we have received the commitment letter and are reviewing the terms," Lake Express principal David Lubar told The Chronicle late Monday from his Milwaukee office. "If we are able to accept those terms, we will have formal press conferences (in Muskegon and Milwaukee) in the next 48 hours to make the announcement."

The Muskegon announcement is expected to be made in conjunction with Thursday's Muskegon Economic Forum luncheon at the Muskegon Country Club, featuring an address by Gov. Jennifer Granholm.

At that time, Lubar said his company should be able to determine the timing of the ship construction and the beginning of the high-speed ferry service.

" We have full expectation that it will be good news," he said.

Plans are for Lake Express to use the federal loan guarantee to secure private sector funding for the $18 million launch of a new ship and cross-lake service. The federal loan guarantee should provide Lake Express with more favorable interest rates from a private lender.

Lake Express will build a 191-foot catamaran jet boat at Austal USA in Mobile, Ala. The Australian-designed twin-hulled aluminum boat should carry 250 passengers and 46 vehicles.

The new ferry should be capable of speeds of 35 mph crossing Lake Michigan, making a dock-to-dock trip in two hours and 20 minutes, according to Lake Express officials. Lake Express plans three-round trips a day with a season from May to November.

The existing Lake Michigan Carferry's operation of the SS Badger between Ludington and Manitowoc, Wis., can carry 620 passengers and 185 cars. The Badger makes two round trips a day at speeds of 18 mph with a four-hour crossing. Fares between the two services are expected to be comparable.

One remaining question is where a high-speed ferry will dock in Muskegon. The city will lease a ferry dock to Lake Express but that location has yet to be determined.

Lake Express officials have attempted to come to an agreement with the West Michigan Dock & Market Corp. for its downtown Mart Dock. The backup dock location for the Mart Dock is city land adjacent to the Hartshorn Municipal Marina.

Receiving a "Title 11" loan guarantee was no easy ticket for Lake Express and their supporters in Milwaukee and Muskegon. The federal ship-building assistance program had run into a political buzzsaw in Washington with conservatives calling it "corporate welfare."

The program -- which provides federally funded guarantees if the loans were to go bad -- had several loans fail, some major ones for construction of huge ocean-going cruise ships. Title 11 is designed to assist the U.S. ship-building industry, which has trouble competing against foreign shipbuilders due to labor costs.

At the same time, interests in Ludington and Wisconsin lobbied hard against the Lake Express application in support of the only cross-lake operation, Lake Michigan Carferry and its SS Badger. Lake Michigan Carferry officials thought the federal loan guarantee was "unfair" competition and that Lake Express would threaten the Ludington service.

Lake Michigan Carferry President and co-owner Bob Manglitz was dejected Monday when he learned of the Maritime Administration decision.

" We think it is extremely unfair for the U.S. government to compete against us," Manglitz said.

Maritime Administration spokeswoman Robyn Boerstling said the Lake Express application had to be reviewed by the U.S. Department of Transportation's Inspector General's Office. Congress has put restrictions on the Title 11 program rules that had to be reviewed by the Inspector General, she said.

In deciding the federal loan guarantee, Maritime Administration officials concluded that Lake Express and the Lake Michigan Carferry offer two different experiences providing two different travel products geared toward different markets. Ludington supporters say there is one, limited market.

About eight weeks ago Lake Express received positive signs from the Maritime Administration and decided to begin construction of the ship. Lubar said construction began in design and initial hull work but it was stopped when the political hurdles for the application arose.

Lubar said his company now must work out schedule details with Austal.

Relinking Muskegon and Milwaukee will be a huge boost to Muskegon and West Michigan tourism, community leaders predict. A Muskegon Area Chamber of Commerce analysis shows that 150,000 passengers a year will bring $26 million in additional economic activity to Muskegon. Lake Express is expected to create 50 permanent jobs.

" This is the most fabulous announcement I have heard in my career," said Joanne Hatch, tourism development director for Muskegon County. "This will double the tourist interest in our community and all of West Michigan."

Chamber Board Chairman Russ Strong said the cross-lake ferry service will "put us on the map." Besides bringing more people through town, the ferry service will improve Muskegon's image throughout the entire West Michigan region, he said.

Muskegon County government -- which in 1987 put a bond issue before voters for renovation of an existing ship for a cross-lake ferry system -- has been promoting resumption of cross-lake ferry service for decades. County Board Chairman Paul Baade said he was "thrilled" with the news.

" All I have heard my whole life about Muskegon is potential, potential, potential," Baade said. "Doggone it, we're now going to realize that potential."

© 2003 Muskegon Chronicle. Used with permission
 
Printable Version

“On August 11, 2001, we celebrated 50 years in Western Michigan. You don’t do that without excellent relationships with everybody.”

Mike Pepper,
General Manager
Howmet Corporation
an Alcoa Business
 
Hot Topics | About MAF | Contact Us | Site Map | Other Links